The problem: The CISO buys a vulnerability scanner (a tool that checks servers for known weaknesses) to scan about 300 servers each night. IT already pays for a scanning module inside its asset management tool, and it scans the same servers. Now two scans run on each server, the servers slow down at night, and the two tools give two different lists of weaknesses.
Words used here: a vulnerability is a known weakness that an attacker could use. A scanner is a tool that looks for them. An asset tool keeps a list of the company’s servers, laptops and software. Overlap means two tools doing the same job.
Think of two neighbours with one lawn
Two neighbours share a back lawn. Neither knows the other has a mower. Each mows on Saturday morning, and the grass is cut twice. One of them buys a second mower because “the first one is not fast enough.” Both mowers sit in separate sheds. Nobody has looked in the other shed.
The two scanners are the two mowers.
What it looks like at work
The CISO has a real need. The IT scan runs weekly, and the CISO wants it nightly. IT has not been asked, and IT has not offered. The new scanner is bought on the security budget, with no check of what IT already has. These are example numbers.
Within a month, server owners complain about slow performance at night. The security analyst has one list from each tool. They disagree on about a fifth of the findings, and nobody knows which is right. Finance sees two invoices for something that looks the same.
- 11. Real needSecurity wants nightly scans, IT scans weekly
- 22. BoughtOn the security budget, IT never asked
- 33. Two scansBoth tools hit the same 300 servers
- 44. Slow serversOwners complain about night performance
- 55. Two listsAbout a fifth of the findings disagree
Both sides have a fair point. Security needs scans that run often and that it controls. IT is right that it owns the servers, and extra load on them is its problem. Neither wanted to duplicate. They just never compared lists.
You will notice it when:
- Two teams talk about “the scan” and mean different tools.
- Server owners ask which scan is making things slow.
- Two reports show different findings for the same server.
- A tool is bought without asking what the company already owns.
- Nobody can produce a list of all security and IT tools with their owners.
What exactly needs fixing
The fix is not to blame the buyer. It is one list of the tools the company owns, a habit of checking that list before buying, and one tool named as the master source for weaknesses. This card shows the whole problem on one page:
Security and IT each run a scanner on the same 300 servers, and the lists of weaknesses disagree.
The new scanner, the asset tool’s scan module, and the night scan window.
A serious weakness is on one list but not the other and is not fixed.
- A second licence
- Slower servers
- Wasted time
- No master list
- 11. One tool listName, owner, what it does, cost and renewal date
- 22. Ask before buying“Have we checked the list, and asked IT?” before any purchase
- 33. Pick one masterCompare on ten servers, then choose one source of truth
Who fixes it: CISO and head of IT
By when: master list agreed before the next renewal
A blank copy of this card is in the Tools section.
Why it happens
- Each team has its own budget. Neither sees the other’s purchases.
- Tools come in modules. Teams do not know what is switched on.
- There is no single tool list. So nobody can check.
- A new tool feels like a quick answer. Sorting out the old one takes work.
- Tool names hide the overlap. One calls it a scanner, the other a module.
What happens if you ignore it
The company pays twice and trusts neither answer.
- Server owners stop co-operating with scans because of the slowdown.
- The two lists disagree, so fixes wait for a decision on which list counts.
- Both tools renew each year, because nobody dares switch one off.
- Auditors ask which tool is the source of truth, and nobody can say.
At a glance
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| How likely is it to hurt us? | Likely, in any company with separate IT and security budgets. |
| Worst case? | A serious weakness is on one list but not the other and is not fixed. |
| What does it cost? | A second licence, slower servers, and wasted time. |
| What if we wait? | Both renew, and the habit continues. |
| What does the fix cost? | A tool list and one decision. |
How to fix it, step by step
List what you own, ask before you buy, then pick one master.
- Make one list of tools. Name, owner, what it does, what it costs, and renewal date.
- Mark where two tools do the same job. Start with scanning, logging, backups and sign-in.
- Compare the two scanners on the same ten servers. Look at speed, accuracy, and reports.
- Choose one as the master list. Use the other only where it adds something.
- Agree the schedule. One scan window, so servers are not scanned twice.
- Add a step before any purchase. “Have we checked the tool list, and have we asked IT?”
- Decide at renewal. Do not renew both without a reason.
The picture shows the order: list what you own, ask before you buy, then pick one master. The first step is dull, and it pays for itself the first time it stops a purchase.
Who to bring in: The CISO and the head of IT (agree the choice), the owner of the asset tool (keeps the list), server owners (tell you about the slowdown), and finance (sees both invoices).
Tools and templates
Tool overlap list
| Tool | Owner | What it does | Cost per year | Renewal date | Overlaps with |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scanner (security) | Finds weaknesses | Asset tool module | |||
| Asset tool (IT) | Lists servers and scans | Scanner |
Blank finding card
| Field | Write here |
|---|---|
| What is broken | One line, in plain words |
| Where it is | The system, team, or process |
| What could go wrong | In one sentence |
| What it costs us | Money, time, a failed audit, lost trust |
| The fix | The exact action |
| Who fixes it | One name or one team |
| By when | A date, not “soon” |
Email to start the talk
Subject: Two scanners on the same servers
Hi. I think we have two tools scanning the same servers: the new scanner from security and the module in your asset tool. The servers are slowing down at night and our two lists do not match. Could we meet for 30 minutes to compare the two and decide which one is the master list? I am not looking to criticise either purchase. I would like us to avoid paying twice and to have one list we both trust.
Field tip
Before you buy any tool, ask in one message: “Does anyone already own something that does this?” It takes a minute.
Words used in this chapter
- Vulnerability: a known weakness that an attacker could use.
- Scanner: a tool that looks for vulnerabilities.
- Asset tool: a tool that keeps a list of the company’s devices and software.
- Overlap: two tools doing the same job.
- Master list: the one list everyone agrees to act on.
- Renewal: the date a licence must be paid again.